These bagels y’all? They tasted SO good with pumpkin spice peanut butter and regular peanut butter.
It’s no secret that I love peanut butter on everything from bagels to yogurt. Why do I love peanut butter or at least eat it more than any other nut butters?
1. It’s cheaper.
2. There are so many more versions of peanut butter (flavors) than any other kind of nut butter.
3. It’s easily accessible in any country.
I love giving gifts. It’s just SO fun, and I think the best part is that it reminds
Without further delay for today’s Thinking out Loud with Amanda, I present to you my Peanut Butter Lover’s Gift Guide ranking them by price and taste (from my personal preferences.) I’m also going to list some that I have been ‘hoping’ to try, but I have not tried them yet. I guess you could say that they are still on my ‘peanut butter bucket list.’ I would LOVE for you to share more ideas in the comments!
My Very Favorite Peanut Butter I had This Year
Peanut Butter&CO Cinnamon Raisin Peanut Butter
Taste: 10/10 – ‘Nuff said. 
Price: 6/10
My 2nd Favorite Peanut Butter
Kirkland Organic Creamy Peanut Butter
Taste: 8/10 (It’s probably the most ‘peanuty’ peanut butter that I’ve had over Justin’s Peanut Butter)
Price: 9/10 (You DEFINITELY get the most bang for your buck on this, and the ingredients list is SOO short.)
My 3rd Favorite Peanut Butter
Trader Joe’s Pumpkin Spice Cookie Butter
Taste: 9/10 (Not too sweet. And it DEFINITELY tastes so much like pumpkin)
Price: 7/10
My 4th Favorite Peanut Butter:
PB&CO Pumpkin Spice Peanut Butter
Taste: 9/10
Price: 6.5/10 – The price is pretty good on this, but I just can’t spend $5+ on a peanut butter jar every time I buy peanut butter
so PB&CO are definitely more of a treat for me.
My 5th Favorite Peanut Butter
Jif Natural Crunchy Peanut Butter
Taste: 7/10 – It’s not the absolute BEST crunchy peanut butter I’ve had, but I loved the fact that it
was SO CHEAP, and it was also natural (AKA: very short ingredients list.)
Price: 10/10
My 6th Favorite Peanut Butter
PB&CO Crunch Time Peanut Butter
Taste: 7/10
Price: 7/10 (More expensive than the Jif Crunchy, so I would rate it a bit lower on the scale. The tastes were very
comparable. Of course I’m not nearly the peanut butter connoisseur that Rebekah is or that Georgie is on almond butter)
My 7th Favorite Peanut Butter
PB&CO’s White Chocolate Wonderful
Taste: 7/10 -There’s nothing that particularly strikes you about ‘White Chocolate Wonderful’, but
I still REALLY like how creamy, smooth, and sweet it is (without having much sugar in it at all.
I think the reason that it doesn’t have a very definitive flavor is that white chocolate is a very mild flavored candy,
therefore making it a bit milder.)
Price: 7/10
My 8th Favorite ‘Nut Butter’
NUTELLA!!!
Ok, this is totally cheating. I know that it doesn’t count as a ‘nut butter’, more like
chocolate frosting, but I am thankful that God gave someone the idea of making Nutella. It’s
made for so many wonderful memories with my sweet family.
Nut Butters I would Like to Try:
1. Wild Friend’s Sugar Cookie Butter
2. Crazy Richard’s Nut Butter Sampler (per Kaila’s suggestion.)
3. Barney Butter’s Honey and Flax Peanut Butter
4. PB&CO’s Popular Peanut Butter Packs (I have tried these peanut butters, but this is A GOOD DEAL!)
5. Teddie Peanut Butter – I have heard some really good reviews on these.
Have you tried any of these peanut butters?
What’s your favorite nut butter?
Do you have a favorite nut butter that isn’t listed here?
The post Favorite Peanut Butter Gift Guide appeared first on Beauty In Christ - The Book.